Department of FoodieDepartment of Foodie
Established Madison Square Garden-area staple serving pizzas whole and by the slice.
What to order: Upside‑Down Grandma Slice · Sicilian Sausage Slice · Vegan White (or Vegan Classic/Margarita)From Google Maps reviews.
NY Pizza Suprema is a true NYC classic that has been serving pizza since 1964. They offer around 25 different kinds of pies, including vegan options, so there’s something for everyone. The slices have a perfectly thin, foldable crust, flavorful sauce, and just the right amount of cheese. Just make sure you know what slice you want before you get to the counter because this place gets busy and they’ll have you ordering quickly. Located right across from Penn Station, it’s one of the best spots to
NY Pizza Suprema is my favourite pizza place whenever I'm in New York. I've tried a few of the famous pizza spots, but this one is still at the top of my list. What I love most is the taste and flavour. It actually reminds me of the pizzas I had in Rome and Milan—simple, fresh, and full of flavour without trying too hard. The crust, the cheese, and the sauce just come together really well. Every slice feels like proper Italian-style pizza rather than just another New York slice. If you're vis
NY Pizza Suprema right outside Madison Square Garden is an absolute go-to spot if you’re looking to grab a slice (or a few) at any time of day. I had a layover at the train station nearby and knew I had to take advantage of being in NYC to get some quality pizza- and this place delivered. At first, the slices might seem a little pricey, but once you see the size, it makes total sense. They’re huge, filling, and packed with flavor, making it well worth the cost. The pizza itself was exactly wha
From the Apr 14, 2025 health inspection. Lower-priority items are listed after the serious ones.
Food was left exposed to possible contamination during storage, prep, or serving.
Shelves, ledges, or equipment exteriors aren't clean or easy to clean.
Plumbing issues: poor drainage, backflow risk, or wastewater handled improperly.