Department of FoodieDepartment of Foodie
Brick-oven pizza, pasta & Italian heros are the hearty basics supplied by this family-run joint.
What to order: Quattro Stagioni pizza · Margherita Pizza · Cheesesteak HoagieFrom Google Maps reviews.
Peppino’s in Park Slope is absolutely fantastic. The food quality is A+. For starters, it was the best bruschetta I’ve ever had - no exaggeration. The pizza was perfect. I’m not a big pepperoni guy but this place does it right 👌. Pies cooked to perfection. Cheesesteak hoagies were excellent. Oozing cheese, peppers, onions 🤤… wish I took more photos for this review. My group had a small feast and everyone was happy. Delicious food and even better customer service. Must go. 5 stars!!
Came highly recommended by fellow pizza lovers and Peppino’s did not disappoint! Their pizza was light, crispy, and the cheese had plenty of pull. Very flavorful from the sauce to the crust. Very comfortable dine-in spot for an easy night, since everything is a stone throw away. Very family and children friendly. Easily up there with some of the best slices BK has to offer! Try for yourself and bet you’ll agree.
I came to Peppino’s for the 4 Stagioni and left genuinely impressed. The pizza was outstanding — fresh ham, mushrooms, olives, and artichokes layered over a rich tomato sauce with perfectly melted mozzarella. Every ingredient tasted clean, authentic, and perfectly balanced. The brick-oven crust had that ideal mix of crisp and chew with just the right char. You can truly taste the pride and tradition in every bite. The service was great from start to finish — friendly, welcoming, and attentive w
From the Jan 23, 2026 health inspection. Lower-priority items are listed after the serious ones.
Food surfaces weren't washed and sanitized between uses.
Food was left exposed to possible contamination during storage, prep, or serving.