Department of FoodieDepartment of FoodieRelaxed pizzeria serving large slices of New York-style pies alongside Italian comfort food.
What to order: giant slice · beef patty with cheese · sausage pizzaFrom Google Maps reviews.
I had to write a review this time. The last 3 times got me really disappointed. The service is always great and they have been there for a long time. I feel like there is no love with their food anymore. The slice was really dry, I had to put some melted butter on it when I got home. And the cheese seems less too. Before, their slice was a big perfect triangle and now it is an obtuse triangle (google it) you cannot cut that in half to share with someone like before. And it is not the first time
12/17/2025 Visited for lunch. Got the beef patty with cheese, which was extra and the guy didn’t tell me. You have to be up front with people, the cheese was a $2 up charge, so instead of a $4 patty it was $6. The patty was good and it was good with cheese, but being sneaky to make a quick buck is never okay. The slices are enormous, I may come back to try them. 3 booths inside, it was clean.
Pretty decent pizza shop. Been around for a while since I was a kid. The pizza server is always nice and kind. This is the only pizza shop in the castle hill area the next one is off the bruckner. Now I do think 5.50 for a slice is pretty much. This isn’t thee best pizza around but it’s decent. And the water was 1.50 and that is ridiculous
From the Oct 23, 2025 health inspection. Lower-priority items are listed after the serious ones.
Food surfaces weren't washed and sanitized between uses.