Department of FoodieDepartment of FoodieBagel shop in Seguine Plaza turning out breakfast and sandwiches, plus panini and grilled items.
From Google Maps reviews.
Bagel Box catered breakfast for our Eastern Region Women's Rally at New Dorp Moravian Church last Saturday. The bagels, choices of cream cheese, muffins and croissants were fantastic. They gave us a wonderful set price for 150 guests and more than enough food to send long distance traveller's home with take out bag and still have enough for Sunday church fellowship. Thank you from the bottom of our hearts and wishing you continued success at your Amboy Rd and two other locations. We will certain
The bagels and flavored cream cheese are almost always great. (Like with most bagel shops, its best to buy earlier in the day ... See below.) The problem for me are the high prices, for the most basic items. Recently, I purchased a dozen bagels, and a half-pound of butter, jelly, and 2 types of flavored cream cheese. I was charged $12 per pound for the butter and jelly. This evening, my 4 year-old asked for a rainbow bagel. I was charged $2 for the bagel. With nothing on it. And the bagel was
Friday morning we ordered the French Toast bagel bacon egg and cheese with maple syrup. The sandwich was off the charts! I highly recommend that you try this sandwich. Not only is their food delicious, their customer service is top notch and prices are very reasonable. The store is so clean you can eat off the floor. The staff is amazing and super friendly. Chris, the owner, is the most generous guy to the community which makes the integrity of the store that much more worth the visit.
From the Dec 19, 2025 health inspection. Lower-priority items are listed after the serious ones.
Wiping cloths weren't kept clean, dry, or in sanitizer between uses.
Cold food was held above 41°F, warm enough for bacteria to grow.