Department of FoodieDepartment of Foodie
Old-school soda shop dispensing sundaes, egg creams & comfort food in a former pharmacy setting.
What to order: Chocolate Egg Cream · Milkshakes (e.g. Black & White Milkshake, Strawberry Milksha · Giant Sundaes (e.g. More Is S’mores Sundae, hot fudge sundaeFrom Google Maps reviews.
Had the sweetest date night here with my boyfriend two big ice cream lovers, and Brooklyn Farmacy did not disappoint. We ordered the black & white milkshake and the caramel apple pie sundae. Both were delicious and massive. We couldn’t finish them, but every bite was worth it.
Cozy corner store with delicious ice cream and floats. The sweetness just perfect! Not overly sweet just perfect!
Vear lovely ice cream shop, great to bring the family or a date. Prices are on the higher end but the portion are great to share. Definitely would come back to try more of the menu. The staff were very nice and outdoor seating spaces is available. Cash and credit are both accepted. Parking in the area is very limited but available depending on the time. 08/2025
From the Mar 10, 2026 health inspection. Lower-priority items are listed after the serious ones.
Food surfaces are too worn or badly built to be properly cleaned.