Department of FoodieDepartment of FoodieCasual restaurant in the Hylan Shopping Center dishing up pies, Sicilian slices, pastas, and sandwiches, plus wings.
What to order: Panelle (pannelle) sandwich · Neighborhood Heroes · Sicilian slice · Rice Ball ParmFrom Google Maps reviews.
The chicken tenders were burnt, rubbery like it was refried. Garlic Knots were hard, personal pie was cold. The entire meal was warm to almost cold. This is not the first time it has happened. I will no longer order food from this establishment. The wax paper for the pizza was from Wendy’s. 🤨 Does the owner also own Wendy’s?
2/19/26 Review update, had to share, yesterday they offered a special, pan pasta, cut into rectangle blocks, breaded and fried, to be eaten like street food, it's a home run, they are prepping more for today, get it while it lasts‼️ Let's deal with atmosphere, it's a pizzeria, nothing fancy, but for me Rob and Joe and their employees are like family, I work across the street and have been coming here since 2017. Always friendly, can always get something good to eat and isn't that all we ask for
We’ve been ordering from Brooklyn’s Finest for over six years, and it has consistently been our go-to spot. The food is always fresh and absolutely delicious. We order at least twice a week (sometimes more!), and every meal has been outstanding. The owner, Rob, is fantastic, and the entire staff is friendly, professional, and always welcoming. With so many options out there, we always find ourselves coming back here—it truly lives up to its name as Brooklyn’s Finest. Highly recommended!
From the Jun 22, 2026 health inspection. Lower-priority items are listed after the serious ones.
Evidence of mice was found on site.
Food was left exposed to possible contamination during storage, prep, or serving.
Flies were present in the space.
Gaps, cracks, or clutter make it easy for pests to get in and nest.
Shelves, ledges, or equipment exteriors aren't clean or easy to clean.