Department of FoodieDepartment of FoodieFrom Google Maps reviews.
I've been wanting to try this place and was so happy to see them open in the UES which is way closer to me! We tried the odyssey, the cyclops, the ithaca, the athena & the penelope. They were all delicious but our top picks were the odyssey, cyclops & ithaca! If you're not sure what to get, they have mini versions! The cookies were warm, ooey, gooey and not too sweet. Think mini cookie skillets! We dined in and Angelos was super sweet and accommodating (: Highly recommend and we will be stoppin
The establishment is small but there is a small area to eat. The display of cookies looked amazing. There was a sampler dish to try some of the cookies. We opted for the Oreo which was just cooked (around 9p) surprised to find out they were still baking stuff so late at night. The cookie is massive, generous on the toppings, not too sweet. It is more on the soft side rather than crunchy. It is thick.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Absolutely outstanding experience at Cookie Odyssey. The cookies are genuinely incredible, easily better than Crumbl, both in flavor and texture. But what really sets this place apart is the service. My girlfriend wanted a very specific cookie that had just sold out, and instead of brushing it off, they immediately offered to bake a fresh batch on the spot. While I waited a about 10mon minutes, they even gave me a free cookie, completely unprompte, which felt as such a thoughtful gesture.
From the May 26, 2026 health inspection. Lower-priority items are listed after the serious ones.
Evidence of mice was found on site.
No food thermometer available to check cooking and holding temperatures.
Food was left exposed to possible contamination during storage, prep, or serving.
Plumbing issues: poor drainage, backflow risk, or wastewater handled improperly.
Single-use items were reused or left unprotected.
Gaps, cracks, or clutter make it easy for pests to get in and nest.