Department of FoodieDepartment of FoodieModest pizza joint known for thin-crust pies for dine-in, takeout or delivery.
From Google Maps reviews.
If you’re looking for that real late-night NYC pizza vibe, this spot never disappoints. Me and my boyfriend were craving a classic late-night slice and decided to try it, and honestly we were hooked right away. The first time we ordered from here, it was so good we ended up ordering again not long after. The pizza has that perfect NYC feel — the kind that reminds you of the old 99¢ slice spots. Crispy crust, cheesy, simple, and exactly what you want when you’re craving real New York pizza late
Fast service. Got three slices ($9), couldn't wait 10 minutes for a pizza pie($12). Great price. Its the heart of NYC you cannot go wrong with eating pizza from anywhere around here. Visiting from FL you know I miss this thin crust goodness 😊Thanks guys!
Continuing my hunt for the best regular slice on the UES, and tried Gotham Pizza on this beautiful Sunday night in June. Ordered a regular slice and a margherita slice, and they were fair. Just meeting NY standards, and I’d give their regular slice a 7.1/10. The marg slice was also fair, probably a 7.4/10. The crusts on both were nice and thin, but the flavors weren’t anything super special. They were good, but not great. They didn’t take my pants off, or whatever the kids say these days. Good
From the Feb 12, 2026 health inspection. Lower-priority items are listed after the serious ones.
Food surfaces weren't washed and sanitized between uses.
Contaminated food was kept instead of being thrown out.