Department of FoodieDepartment of Foodie
Casual pizzeria dishing up regular and vodka pies, plus sandwiches, pasta, and Italian entrees.
From Google Maps reviews.
The restaurant is located in the Bensonhurst section of Brooklyn. They prepare Italian/Mexican cuisine. Several tables are available for dining in but there are no servers. Pizza, burgers 🍔, hot dogs, salads, sandwiches 🥪, heroes, appetizers, entrees, pasta, rolls, sides, special family specials, desserts and beverages are available. I ordered a pizza, garden salad and pasta with clam sauce. The food was average in taste and flavor.
I miss when this place was Nicky's Pizza. They had the best regular slices. Obviously if there is so much things on the menu of Gus's Pizza the quality won't be the same. Pizza should be strictly focused on pizza pasta calzones and other things a pizzeria is known to have, not all this other crap. The more food that's added to the menu the more the quality will go downhill. Save yourself the money and go to Pino's Pizza also on Bath Avenue Brooklyn 2025 Bath Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11214. Nothing will
Pizza is pretty good here and they have in stock Vanilla Coke so that’s a huge plus for me. I got a regular slice and an upside down slice with a cheese cake and a coke. I hope more people swing by and grab a pie to take home cuz the pizza hits good
From the Jul 11, 2026 health inspection. Lower-priority items are listed after the serious ones.
Flies were present in the space.
Evidence of mice was found on site.
Cooked food wasn't cooled down fast enough to be safe.
Hot food was held below 140°F, cool enough for bacteria to grow.
Gaps, cracks, or clutter make it easy for pests to get in and nest.