Department of FoodieDepartment of FoodieAn Italian-American menu & counter-serve options featuring slices, pies & more in a casual setting.
What to order: Sicilian Pizza · Baked Ziti · Chicken ParmigianaFrom Google Maps reviews.
I ordered penne pasta with vodka sauce and clearly this pasta does not have vodka sauce. It taste like mac and cheese and also very dry. They also added tomato sauce to the chicken which is awful. I called and told them that I think my order was messed up and the guy was not helpful at all and told me that “thats the sauce they use that he cant do anything” I am a frequent customer and I would not be ordering from here anymore. Do not recommend!!!
Katonah Pizza & Pasta is a fantastic spot that I always look forward to visiting. I really appreciate their great Sicilian slices, which are thick, flavorful, and consistently delicious. The variety of different types of slices is another big plus, as there’s always something new and tasty to try. This place is especially meaningful to me because my family and friends always stop here when passing through on Halloween, making it part of a fun and memorable tradition. The food, atmosphere, and me
Popped in for a slice and asked if they had a grandma they gave me this weird corner that had heavy tomato and no noticeable garlic or basil. I got a regular slice too, the regular slice was par at best, sauce not outstanding but still better than the tomato breadstick shaped like a square they sold me claiming to be a grandma. These guys need a field trip to little Italy pizza shop on church and chambers to learn what a real grandma slice is
From the Feb 4, 2025 health inspection. Lower-priority items are listed after the serious ones.
Evidence of mice was found on site.
Gaps, cracks, or clutter make it easy for pests to get in and nest.