Department of FoodieDepartment of FoodieFrom Google Maps reviews.
This is one of my favorite gelato places in town. It's authentic and high end. I recommend the Artisanal Cioccolato, Stracciatella, and Cafe flavors. I also like their crepes and Gelato Bonbons. The owner is often there and the service is excellent.
Every time I’m in NYC, La Gelateria di Eataly by Patrizia Pasqualetti is a non-negotiable stop for me. Like… I will rearrange my plans for this gelato. The texture? Insanely smooth. The flavors? Actually taste like what they’re supposed to (rare these days tbh). And I’m not even being dramatic when I say the pistachio is life-changing - rich, nutty, not overly sweet… just perfect. The whole vibe inside Eataly makes it feel like a little Italy moment in the middle of Manhattan, and it’s always
BAR NONE — BEST GELATO IN THE WORLD!!! I have followed this incredibly decadent gelato since I first discovered it and have visited a few of their locations. I love that they offer some different flavors local to each shop. The sorbetto tastes just like you’re eating the actual fruit! The pistachio is incredible, but honestly I always struggle which flavors to choose because THEY ARE ALL AMAZING!!! 😍😍😍 such lovely warm staff! This is the ONLY gelateria around that invites with a true authenti
From the Jun 29, 2026 health inspection. Lower-priority items are listed after the serious ones.
Food was left exposed to possible contamination during storage, prep, or serving.
Staff hygiene fell short: soiled clothing, no hair covering, or unkempt nails.