Department of FoodieDepartment of Foodie
Casual pizzeria serving slices, pies, and Italian comfort foods, with kid-friendly dining.
From Google Maps reviews.
I had a terrible experience at this location. I ordered a whole one topping pizza. I requested that half of the pizza have ham and the other half I wanted pepperoni. They proceeded to put ham and pepperoni on the entire pizza. When I said that wasn’t what I wanted-I was attacked. The cashier was rude when taking my payment. I asked for a manager and the manager stated he was also the owner. He proceeded to disrespect me in front of my son. I finally requested a refund and he gave me cash minu
Little Italy Pizza is one of my absolute favorite spots every time I’m in Midtown NYC. Consistently delicious slices, fast service, and exactly the kind of classic NYC pizza you crave when you’re in the city. Always a must-stop for me — reliable, satisfying, and so good every single time. 🍕🗽
The pizza here is above average for sure. There are so many choices to choose from but we all like choices. I have had the plain cheese slice which the crust is done perfectly with semolina and all . I have also had the margarine slice which was outstanding , it had super crunchy crust and fresh basil on it . There’s nothing g like fresh basil and it was fresh. They also have fountain coke which should be staple in all pizza joints and it had a fresh taste which means the soda lines were clean
From the Mar 10, 2026 health inspection. Lower-priority items are listed after the serious ones.
No proper toilet for staff or patrons, or it's accessed through the kitchen.
Plumbing issues: poor drainage, backflow risk, or wastewater handled improperly.