Department of FoodieDepartment of FoodieWhat to order: Classic Nagle · Nagles Sunrise · New YorkerFrom Google Maps reviews.
I ordered brunch from this place through Uber Eats and got a classic nagke - the New York style lox bagel sandwich. I swapped the plain cream cheese for jalapeño cream cheese, and the sandwich came with lox, onion, capers, and tomato on an everything bagel. It was pretty good overall — not the best I’ve ever had in NYC, but definitely a solid, decent option with good-quality lox. I also ordered two slices of babka, which were quite thin for the price. The taste was okay, just not particularly m
service is a little slow but the quality of the product and service is why, it’s a bustling and quaint location amongst a bunch of cool little shoppes and the selection/ prices are all great. the bagels are super soft and not too chewy, tuna salad was well seasoned and overall loved this place. they also gave my friend a free gift just cause they inquired if certain things were for sale- love this place!!!
Honestly it bums me out to write this review. I want to like Nagle because I live right around the corner, but it just isn’t the spot. For a bagel and cream cheese that is of comparable price to every other bagel shop in the city, it just doesn’t stack up. The bagel is a little smaller than most, and it never seems like the dough is fully risen. The crumb structure is inconsistent between the center and the crust. And you’re never guaranteed to get enough cream cheese unless you pay for extra.
From the Oct 22, 2025 health inspection. Lower-priority items are listed after the serious ones.
Food was left exposed to possible contamination during storage, prep, or serving.
Staff hygiene fell short: soiled clothing, no hair covering, or unkempt nails.
Shelves, ledges, or equipment exteriors aren't clean or easy to clean.