Department of FoodieDepartment of Foodie
Old-world relic (1868-era) serving huge, pricey steaks in a classic, dark-wood setting.
What to order: Prime 40 Day Dry Aged Rib Steak on the Bone for Two · Japanese Wagyu "A5+" Steak · Our Legendary RibeyeFrom Google Maps reviews.
Side notes- Review is in regards to their $95 special for 2, which is a fantastic deal compared to their standard menu. Also, their website is currently hacked, displaying a page to download a fake version of Chrome from "worshipinnovcations." Finally, this old school steakhouse is posting AI slop on Instagram/their FB page in celebration of the Knicks... "cool." Anyway, I was here a while ago for something that they appear to offer seasonally, the $95 Porterhouse for Two, which is normally $16
This is not the old homestead I remember as a kid. They downsized so when you walk inside it’s like walking into dark cave with no windows, jam packed and super loud. The food itself was ok but not impressed as I hoped it would be. Steaks were tasty but the sides were not what I remember. We got the 12 oysters which were good, 2 colossal shrimp which were super hard and chewy, different steaks: sirloin & filet mignons which were good but the garlic mash potatoes were nothing special. The cream o
Old Homestead Steakhouse – 40-Day Dry-Aged Rib Steak for Two Had a genuinely great experience at Old Homestead Steakhouse. We ordered the 40‑day dry‑aged rib steak for two, medium rare, and it was cooked absolutely perfectly. The beef itself was so flavorful and tender that we didn’t feel the need for any extra sauces or seasoning – it really stood on its own. For sides, we tried the hash brown with egg, which was something different and a fun, satisfying twist compared to the usual steakhous
From the May 5, 2026 health inspection. Lower-priority items are listed after the serious ones.
Contaminated food was kept instead of being thrown out.
Dishes and utensils weren't being properly washed and sanitized.