Department of FoodieDepartment of FoodieCasual, beloved spot for pizza slices and pies, including Sicilian and grandma varieties.
From Google Maps reviews.
Best pizza in Coney Island no questions asked ! My childhood pizza spot and remains to be. I always order to go and never had an issue. The grandma slice, actually all the square slices are special ! Buffalo chicken and pepperoni roll are also my favorites. Only thing to be aware is : There is no bathroom here Not that many tables No music playing 9/10❤️
Brooklyn Coney Island Pizza gives a classic New-York street-style experience — big slices, thin crust, and bold flavor. ⭐ Taste The first bite is all about the thin, foldable crust — slightly crispy outside and soft inside. The tomato sauce tastes tangy and fresh, not overly sweet, while the melted mozzarella cheese adds a creamy richness. Toppings stay balanced, so you can actually taste the dough, sauce, and cheese separately.
I was born and raised in Coney Island, New York, though I eventually moved down to Florida. Ever since I was a kid, I’ve been coming to this pizza spot—it’s always been part of my visits back home. Whenever I’m in New York to see my dad, I make it a point to stop here for what I’ve always considered the best pizza in Coney Island. Usually, I grab my slices to go and enjoy them at home. Today, I decided to treat myself and actually dine in after a quick run to Dollar Tree. I ordered two extra-ch
From the Jan 6, 2026 health inspection. Lower-priority items are listed after the serious ones.
No one on shift holds the required food-safety certificate.