Department of FoodieDepartment of Foodie
From Google Maps reviews.
Sergio’s is one of those rare New York institutions that has survived not by chasing trends, but by ignoring them entirely. Since 1975, this corner shop has practiced a kind of culinary minimalism: no sourdough theatrics, no artisanal posturing, no attempts to reinvent the slice. What you find instead is honest, well‑balanced pizza, prepared with a consistency that borders on craft. The room carries the quiet rhythm of a place that serves its neighborhood rather than the algorithm. The clientel
Delicious!!! I pass this place all the time and finally got take out. The garlic rolls were heavenly. Service was great. They had a great buy one get one special and it was enough food to feed a party of fifteen people. Would eat here again.
This is probably the worst pizza I have ever eaten. I got four pies (BOGO) on uber eats, and I regret ordering from this place. Not only did the delivery guy handle my pizza poorly (see pics), but the pizza is not tasty. In fact, its just disgusting. I ordered a spinach pie and they clearly used frozen spinach, which is fine. But there's barely any cheese on the pizza, the.crust is soggy and it just.tastes terrible. I do not recommend this place
From the Jan 28, 2026 health inspection. Lower-priority items are listed after the serious ones.
Hot food was held below 140°F, cool enough for bacteria to grow.