Department of FoodieDepartment of Foodie
Dessert place with a retro vibe & hard-to-find candies, plus gourmet ice cream, gelato & coffee/tea.
From Google Maps reviews.
Matthew the owner was very pleasant. Honestly guys Ihad tried a lot of ice-cream. I mean from the expensive stuff all the way down. The Sweet Shop hands down has the best ice-cream in NYC! Tons of flavors to choose from, there is also a variety of candy. I enjoyed my pistachio gelato made me think all i had before this one was fake and the Leamon ice was the right mixture of subtle sweet lemon and cool ice.to sum it up going back again
Such a lovely candy shop / ice cream store. Matthew was so friendly and helped us pick out the candies we were looking for—I got so excited to see that they had malt balls and he let us try one. We also had the PB&J sundae which was delicious and perfect to share. Loved it here!
Absolutely loved this place! The Sweet Shop NYC is a paradise for anyone with a sweet tooth. The variety of candies, chocolates, and treats is incredible, and everything looks fresh and beautifully displayed. The staff was friendly and helpful, making the experience even better. The store has a fun, colorful vibe that makes you want to try everything. Perfect spot to grab gifts or satisfy your cravings. Highly recommended!
From the Sep 30, 2025 health inspection. Lower-priority items are listed after the serious ones.
No food thermometer available to check cooking and holding temperatures.