Department of FoodieDepartment of Foodie
Bagel shop serving housemade NYC-style bagels and rainbow ones with a variety of cream-cheese options.
What to order: The Weezer · Bagel with Flavored House Made Cream Cheese · Everything Bagel with Scallion Cream Cheese · Bagel with Lox, Cream Cheese, Onions & TomatoFrom Google Maps reviews.
I had an incredible experience here. After placing my order, I was taking pictures with my camera and Giovani noticed me doing so. He invited me to come to the back and get a glimpse of their bagel-making process. He asked me which kinds I liked, told me to wait a moment, and then came a few minutes later with a sampler of 4 cream cheeses cut and quartered among two halves for me to share with my friend. He came to check on us later to make sure everything was going well. Never had this level of
NYC bagels! Tompkins bagels are top notch: selection & variety, friendly staff and quick to order. Even though there was a line to the door, it moved quickly and still maintained quality. There are a TON of different schmears - too many to write down (see pics). Of special note is that they were quick to correct an order, with a smile.
I have been looking for sourdough bagels in the city and noticed Tompkins has them and needed to come try. Came around noon and minimal line but very long wait by the registers. It took forever for the cashiers to ring everyone up. Once you walk in, you line up and there will be workers taking your order on line and hand you your receipt. Then you’re basically waiting on line to pay while they make your food. I ordered a sourdough bagel toasted with plain cream cheese and got another sourdough
From the Mar 9, 2026 health inspection. Lower-priority items are listed after the serious ones.
Food was left exposed to possible contamination during storage, prep, or serving.
Shelves, ledges, or equipment exteriors aren't clean or easy to clean.