Department of FoodieDepartment of FoodieLongtime fixture with pizza & basic homestyle Italian entrees in a casual dining area.
From Google Maps reviews.
Forest Avenue in Staten Island serves as a sprawling timeline of the borough's culinary heritage, a place where the local pizzeria is not just a business but a community landmark. Cafe Milano stands as a testament to this tradition, acting as a warm, inviting harbor for those navigating the North Shore. To step inside is to be greeted by a staff whose friendliness feels like an extension of a family kitchen rather than a transactional storefront. It is a space where the atmosphere is thick with
Really great pizza in the area. We live on South Shore so we do not usually come by, but we had basketball and we’re in area. Really great pizza. Cooked perfect with excellent undercarriage. No flop at all. Sauce was very good and complimented their dough well. Perfect spice.
I usually order here from time to time never have I ever received a pizza box bend & half of my cheese on the box. I also order Fried calamari & some of it was half cooked some wasn’t. I complained about the pizza because I don’t understand how can a driver deliver something like that & I feel like it was purposely done. I didn’t get to complain about the calamari because I didn’t know half of it was half booked. I even told the guy when I ordered don’t half cook the calamari please & still rece
From the Nov 25, 2025 health inspection. Lower-priority items are listed after the serious ones.
Cold food was held above 41°F, warm enough for bacteria to grow.