Department of FoodieDepartment of Foodie.jpg)
Homey diner with counter stools & an old-fashioned feel dishing up everyday American plates.
What to order: Corned Beef Hash & Eggs · Blueberry Pancakes · Disco FriesFrom Google Maps reviews.
It was our first time there we were on our way to orchard beach and it was our first meal of the day we decided to go to the diner. The place felt like you are in your own home kitchen. From the moment you walk in they greeted you to the moment they sat you down. Our waitress name was Naomi she greeted us and told us the specials of the day, the food was amazing!! The service was A plus. We're definitely going back my husband loved the food!! 🤗
This place has always been my favorite place to eat on City Island. Love the old school nostalgic environment. The place just has a uniquely cool authentic vibe you feel right when you walk in. We always enjoy ordering italian dishes here when we visit.
Cycled 40 miles from south shore Long Island. Got here 9 am and not much options in the area. Spoke to a local jogger and he recommended City Island Diner for its food & comfort. I’m glad I took his advice. Walked in and was politely greeted to an old school diner with counter top seats. I got the front row bar stool facing the cook. Watching the orders come in and the cook dishing out his magic. It’s akin to watching a conductor at a symphony. Close your eyes and listen closely to the eggs
From the Nov 26, 2025 health inspection. Lower-priority items are listed after the serious ones.
Wiping cloths weren't kept clean, dry, or in sanitizer between uses.
Dishes and utensils weren't being properly washed and sanitized.
Vistamar RestaurantGraded A4.8★Latin American Restaurant
Seafood CityGraded A4.2★Seafood Restaurant
Tony's Pier RestaurantGraded A4.3★Seafood Restaurant