Department of FoodieDepartment of Foodie
Fried, broiled & raw seafood, plus a menu of burgers, BBQ & wings, served in a no-frills setting.
What to order: Seafood Combo · Fried Lobster Tails · Seafood Pasta · Pina ColadaFrom Google Maps reviews.
My mom chose Tony’s Pier for her birthday because she wanted a wide variety of seafood in a casual setting. While I originally leaned toward something more formal, she was absolutely right to pick this spot! We ordered the steamed and fried combos so she could sample a bit of everything, and she loved the variety. She also enjoyed the Manhattan Clam Chowder, though she mentioned it could have been served a bit hotter. The only real misses were the baked clams, which were over-seasoned and sligh
I love Tony's, my dad introduced us to this restaurant many years ago since I was a child and let's just say I was born in the 80's😃...their food has always been well made and the environment has been family friendly since I can remember, it is a casual family friendly restaurant where you can get great food! I've been to a few City Island spots and honestly Tony's surpasses most when it comes to flavor at a reasonable price. The owner is also very personable and many of their staff have been
The food was fried and full Of grease Just the way I like it I ordered the fried fish platter with fish of course calamari shrimp clams and scallops it was so much food . I enjoyed every last bite. First time there didn’t know what to expect. Fast quick service inside and outside dining picnic table style seating.
From the Oct 24, 2024 health inspection. Lower-priority items are listed after the serious ones.
Shelves, ledges, or equipment exteriors aren't clean or easy to clean.
Plumbing issues: poor drainage, backflow risk, or wastewater handled improperly.
Single-use items were reused or left unprotected.