Department of FoodieDepartment of Foodie
City Island classic since 1920 for seafood in a lively setting, with outdoor dining & marina views.
What to order: Split Open Lobster Roll · Linguine w/ Mussels in Red or White Garlic Sauce · Sea Shore Famous House SaladFrom Google Maps reviews.
Came here on a gloomy rainy day, but the food and the view definitely cheered us up. We choose to seat where we can see the view of outside so better to chose that side of sitting area where you can see the marina right out the window. This place is really nice, classic waterfront vibe even in bad weather. We ordered a bunch of different things and the portions here are absolutely massive,definitely come hungry or prepare to take leftovers home! At first they brought out a bread basket with a g
Absolutely fantastic first time experience here. We've been going to city Island for decades and more than likely always stick to ajust a few spots especially one that was our "go to" that I'm not going to name. However lately the service, food and overall experience had really fallen off so we decided to try something new n take it right across the street to Sea shore where I have for some reason never been. Let me tell you something...from the decor to the live music to the owners circling aro
Let me tell yah something if you trying to pick a restaurant trying this spot. Amazing Amazing Amazing. Service was absolutely on par. Food was on par. Drinks on par. This restaurant will not disappoint. I just can't stop thinking about the linguine and mussels in red sauce. The fish and chips and the Service.
From the Jun 26, 2025 health inspection. Lower-priority items are listed after the serious ones.
Live roaches were found on site.
Plumbing issues: poor drainage, backflow risk, or wastewater handled improperly.
Gaps, cracks, or clutter make it easy for pests to get in and nest.