umchef

Best restaurants in City Island

36 spots on the books in City Island, Bronx. City health grades, crowd ratings, and what to order, all in one list.

Filter these 36 spotsSee them on the map
  1. Vistamar RestaurantGraded A
    4.8★★★★★★★★★★(11,784)$$Latin American Restaurant · 565 City Island Avenue

    What to order: Seafood Paella · Grilled Octopus

  2. Sammy's FishboxGraded A
    4.3★★★★★★★★★★(10,854)$$Seafood Restaurant · 41 City Island Avenue

    What to order: Our Famous Jumbo Fried Shrimp Special · Sammy's Broiled Combination · Piña Colada

  3. Johnny's Reef RestaurantGraded A
    4.4★★★★★★★★★★(9,483)$$Seafood Restaurant · 2 City Island Avenue

    What to order: Fried Lobster Tails · Steamed Clams · Pina Colada

  4. Seafood CityGraded A
    4.2★★★★★★★★★★(7,870)$$Seafood Restaurant · 459 City Island Avenue

    What to order: Fried Seafood Combo · Fried Shrimp · Crab Legs (Snow Crab Legs or Crab Bites)

  5. Tony's Pier RestaurantGraded A
    4.3★★★★★★★★★★(6,085)$$Seafood Restaurant · 1 City Island Avenue

    What to order: Seafood Combo · Fried Lobster Tails · Seafood Pasta · Pina Colada

  6. City Island Lobster HouseGraded A
    4.4★★★★★★★★★★(5,699)$$Seafood Restaurant · 691 Bridge Street

    What to order: Twin Lobster Tail · Whole Lobster Special · Lobster Roll (Our World Famous) · Ultimate Margarita or Frankenstein cocktail

  7. Crab ShantyGraded A
    4.3★★★★★★★★★★(4,794)$$Restaurant · 361 City Island Avenue

    What to order: Joe V’s Deep Diver Feast · Lobster Special (cluster of crab legs, lobster tail, fried s · Snow Crab Legs with Baltimore Seasoning

  8. Seashore RestaurantGraded A
    4.3★★★★★★★★★★(3,820)$$Seafood Restaurant · 591 City Island Avenue

    What to order: Split Open Lobster Roll · Linguine w/ Mussels in Red or White Garlic Sauce · Sea Shore Famous House Salad

  9. Sammy's Original Shrimp BoxGraded A
    4.2★★★★★★★★★★(3,591)$$Barbecue Restaurant · 64 City Island Avenue

    What to order: Broiled Shrimp Scampi · Lobster (succulent lobster)

  10. Jp's RestaurantGraded A
    4.3★★★★★★★★★★(1,497)$$$Seafood Restaurant · 703 Minnieford Avenue

    What to order: Stuffed fish / stuffed flounder · Whole broiled lobster · Large baked clams (Casino)

  11. Scavello's On The IslandGraded A
    4.5★★★★★★★★★★(526)$$Caterer · 101 City Island Avenue

    What to order: Chicken Martini · Fried Shrimp · Grilled Octopus

  12. The Black WhaleGraded A
    4.6★★★★★★★★★★(514)$$American Restaurant · 279 City Island Avenue

    What to order: Seared Sesame Crusted Tuna with Ginger‑Orange Sauce · Pan‑Seared Tuna · Crab Cake (a la carte or sandwich) · Apple Crisp with Vanilla Ice Cream

  13. City Island Diner , Snug BarGraded A
    4.4★★★★★★★★★★(492)$Diner · 304 City Island Avenue

    What to order: Corned Beef Hash & Eggs · Blueberry Pancakes · Disco Fries

  14. DunkinGraded A
    4★★★★★★★★★★(269)$Coffee Shop · 636 City Island Avenue
  15. Archie's Tap And TableGraded A
    4.6★★★★★★★★★★(219)$$Bar & Grill · 536 City Island Avenue
  16. Clipper CoffeeGraded A
    4.8★★★★★★★★★★(199)$Cafe · 274 City Island Avenue
  17. Little GreeceGraded A
    4.9★★★★★★★★★★(183)Greek Restaurant · 327 City Island Avenue
  18. Morris Yacht & Beach ClubGraded A
    4.6★★★★★★★★★★(171)Marina · 25 City Island Avenue
  19. City Island Yacht ClubGraded A
    4.7★★★★★★★★★★(119)Marina · 63 Pilot Street
  20. City Island Chinese RestaurantGraded A
    4.1★★★★★★★★★★(119)$Chinese Restaurant · 84 City Island Avenue
  21. City Island Pizza CompanyGraded A
    4.9★★★★★★★★★★(90)$$Restaurant · 273 City Island Avenue
  22. Ray's Cafe And RestaurantGraded A
    4.4★★★★★★★★★★(90)$Breakfast Restaurant · 205 City Island Avenue
  23. Little Frida's EateryGraded A
    4.9★★★★★★★★★★(81)$$Mexican Restaurant · 415 City Island Avenue
  24. Man OverboardGraded A
    4.4★★★★★★★★★★(72)Bar · 247 City Island Avenue
  25. Fella's BarGraded A
    4.5★★★★★★★★★★(58)Bar & Grill · 522 City Island Avenue
  26. Sea Breee DeliGraded A
    4.6★★★★★★★★★★(52)$Deli · 325 City Island Avenue
  27. Atik RestaurantNot graded
    4.7★★★★★★★★★★(1,394)Restaurant · 555 City Island Avenue

    What to order: Bluefin Tuna Tartare · Spanish Octopus · Crab Cake · Eggplant Croquettes

  28. Enri LushiNot graded
    4.8★★★★★★★★★★(76)Bar · 414 City Island Avenue
  29. 2 Paizan’S Pizzeria CucinaNot graded
    4.8★★★★★★★★★★(66)Pizza Restaurant · 250 City Island Ave
  30. Baskin-RobbinsNot graded
    3.8★★★★★★★★★★(37)$Ice Cream Shop · 636 City Island Ave
  31. The Silent SeaNot graded
    4.6★★★★★★★★★★(36)Greek Restaurant · 634 City Island Avenue
  32. Augies Deli & PizzeriaGraded B
    4.3★★★★★★★★★★(195)$Deli · 520 City Island Avenue
  33. The Golden HallNot graded
    4.8★★★★★★★★★★(20)Banquet hall · 34 City Island Avenue
  34. Tipsy Bar & LoungeNot graded
    4.8★★★★★★★★★★(76)Bar · 414 City Island Avenue
  35. La Mezcaleria By VistamarNot graded
    4.4★★★★★★★★★★(11)Restaurant · 565 City Island Ave
  36. Lickety SplitNot graded
    4.6★★★★★★★★★★(5)Ice Cream Shop · 295 City Island Avenue

What City Island cooks

Seafood11American8Mediterranean2Deli2Chinese1Coffee1Bakery1Italian1Mexican1Pizza1

More of Bronx

Fordham194Longwood166Belmont155Mott Haven138Concourse136Kingsbridge131Parkchester118Norwood110Wakefield100Throgs Neck97Soundview91Allerton77