Department of FoodieDepartment of Foodie
Bustling restaurant supplying a wide range of seafood & fruity cocktails amid ocean-themed decor.
What to order: Broiled Shrimp Scampi · Lobster (succulent lobster)From Google Maps reviews.
This place was a 5 outta 5!!! I've never been to any of the Sammy's places on City Island so I'm happy we started with this one. We came here for my momxs birthday dinner and the food was huge and delicious. They greeted us as soon as we walked in. The service reminded me of me at work, joking with the customers and just making u feel so welcomed. When I was reading up on the menu i was skeptical about the sizes for the prices but I must say it exceeded my expectations. I ordered the Pit Master
My fiancé and I came here to celebrate his birthday and we were not at all disappointed. The food was amazing, everything was bursting with freshness and flavor. The value for the money is acceptable. The service was also incredible. The atmosphere was relaxing and clean. 10/10 recommend and we will definitely be back! The ease of parking is also a huge plus and the location.
Doug the Manager is absolutely the best, his ENERGY is MAGNETIC!! Jose and Santos customer service was awesome! The food was fantastic. The portion sizes were great for a single person or a couple wanting to share the experience. We'll seasoned and filling enough to take some home.
From the Nov 26, 2025 health inspection. Lower-priority items are listed after the serious ones.
Wiping cloths weren't kept clean, dry, or in sanitizer between uses.
Food surfaces weren't washed and sanitized between uses.
Shelves, ledges, or equipment exteriors aren't clean or easy to clean.