Best Seafood spots in NYC

1. 
   Vistamar RestaurantGraded A

   4.8★★★★★★★★★★(11,784)$$Latin American Restaurant · 565 City Island Avenue

   What to order: Seafood Paella · Grilled Octopus

2. 
   Sammy's FishboxGraded A

   4.3★★★★★★★★★★(10,854)$$Seafood Restaurant · 41 City Island Avenue

   What to order: Our Famous Jumbo Fried Shrimp Special · Sammy's Broiled Combination · Piña Colada

3. 
   Johnny's Reef RestaurantGraded A

   4.4★★★★★★★★★★(9,483)$$Seafood Restaurant · 2 City Island Avenue

   What to order: Fried Lobster Tails · Steamed Clams · Pina Colada

4. 
   Red LobsterGraded A

   4.1★★★★★★★★★★(8,637)$$Seafood Restaurant · 455 Gateway Drive

   What to order: Garlic Shrimp Scampi · Half Dozen Cheddar Bay Biscuits® · Shrimp Linguini Alfredo · Crispy Dragon Shrimp®

5. 
   Seafood CityGraded A

   4.2★★★★★★★★★★(7,870)$$Seafood Restaurant · 459 City Island Avenue

   What to order: Fried Seafood Combo · Fried Shrimp · Crab Legs (Snow Crab Legs or Crab Bites)

6. 
   Tony's Pier RestaurantGraded A

   4.3★★★★★★★★★★(6,085)$$Seafood Restaurant · 1 City Island Avenue

   What to order: Seafood Combo · Fried Lobster Tails · Seafood Pasta · Pina Colada

7. 
   City Island Lobster HouseGraded A

   4.4★★★★★★★★★★(5,699)$$Seafood Restaurant · 691 Bridge Street

   What to order: Twin Lobster Tail · Whole Lobster Special · Lobster Roll (Our World Famous) · Ultimate Margarita or Frankenstein cocktail

8. 
   CatchGraded A

   4.2★★★★★★★★★★(5,052)$$$Restaurant · 21 9 Avenue

   What to order: CATCH ROLL · “HIT ME” CHOCOLATE CAKE · Baked Lobster Mac & Cheese · Truffle Sashimi

9. 
   Hook & Reel Cajun Seafood And BarGraded A

   4.8★★★★★★★★★★(4,551)$$Seafood Restaurant · 133-40 79 Street

   What to order: Seafood boil (Hook & Reel sauce, spicy/extra spicy) · Catfish basket (lunch special) · Milk tea

10. 
    Crab ShantyGraded A

    4.3★★★★★★★★★★(4,794)$$Restaurant · 361 City Island Avenue

    What to order: Joe V’s Deep Diver Feast · Lobster Special (cluster of crab legs, lobster tail, fried s · Snow Crab Legs with Baltimore Seasoning

11. 
    Oyster BarGraded A

    4.2★★★★★★★★★★(4,615)$$Oyster Bar Restaurant · Grand Central Terminal

    What to order: Half dozen raw oysters (varieties like Nisqually, Shigoku, G · Oysters Rockefeller · New England Clam Chowder · Dirty Martini

12. 
    Lobster Place Raw BarGraded A

    4.5★★★★★★★★★★(3,803)$$$Seafood Restaurant · 75 9 Avenue

    What to order: Maine Lobster Roll (4 oz or 6 oz) · Roe Boat Lobster Roll · raw oysters · whole steamed lobster

13. 
    Lobster Place SushiGraded A

    4.5★★★★★★★★★★(3,803)$$$Seafood Restaurant · 75 9 Avenue

    What to order: Maine Lobster Roll · Fresh Steamed Lobster · Oysters · Hokkaido don (from sushi bar)

14. 
    Sarge'sGraded A

    4.3★★★★★★★★★★(3,866)$$Deli · 548 3 Avenue

    What to order: Pastrami Reuben (Robin) · Matzo Ball Soup · Hot Pastrami Sandwich · Cheesecake

15. 
    Nick's LobstersGraded A

    4.3★★★★★★★★★★(3,823)$$Seafood Restaurant · 2777 Flatbush Avenue

    What to order: Nick’s Lobster Roll · Lobster Cream Pasta · Oysters

16. 
    Seashore RestaurantGraded A

    4.3★★★★★★★★★★(3,820)$$Seafood Restaurant · 591 City Island Avenue

    What to order: Split Open Lobster Roll · Linguine w/ Mussels in Red or White Garlic Sauce · Sea Shore Famous House Salad

17. 
    Red LobsterGraded A

    4★★★★★★★★★★(3,890)$$Seafood Restaurant · 2090 Bartow Avenue

    What to order: Seaside Shrimp Trio · Half Dozen Cheddar Bay Biscuits® · Parrot Isle Coconut Shrimp

18. 
    The AtticGraded A

    4.9★★★★★★★★★★(3,478)$$Bar · 136-93 37 Avenue

    What to order: The Gunpowder cocktail · Oysters (especially during happy hour) · Wagyu Beef Burger (or Attic Burger) · Short Rib with Bone Marrow

19. 
    Aqua BoilGraded A

    4.7★★★★★★★★★★(3,480)$$Seafood Restaurant · 750 9 Avenue

    What to order: Mad Ocean Combo · Aqua Roll · Lobster Roll · Lobster Mac N' Cheese

20. 
    Sammy's Original Shrimp BoxGraded A

    4.2★★★★★★★★★★(3,591)$$Barbecue Restaurant · 64 City Island Avenue

    What to order: Broiled Shrimp Scampi · Lobster (succulent lobster)

21. 
    Lenny's Clam BarGraded A

    4.4★★★★★★★★★★(3,316)$$Seafood Restaurant · 161-03 Crossbay Boulevard

    What to order: Baked Clams · Fried Calamari (Calabrese) · Lobster Bisque · Captain’s Platter

22. 
    Randazzo's Clam BarGraded A

    4.3★★★★★★★★★★(2,926)$$Seafood Restaurant · 2017 Emmons Avenue

    What to order: Fried Calamari w/ Medium or Hot Sauce · Spicy Crab Corn Chowder · New England Clam Chowder · Pasta Combo with Lobster & Shrimp Sauce

23. 
    Hook & Reel Cajun Seafood & BarGraded A

    4.6★★★★★★★★★★(2,820)$$Seafood Restaurant · 2590 B&C Hylan Blvd

    What to order: The Cajun Boil · The Perfect Storm · The Reel’s Catch · Fries with Crabmeat

24. 
    Ibn Hamido SeafoodGraded A

    4.5★★★★★★★★★★(2,720)$$Seafood Restaurant · 31-29 Ditmars Boulevard

    What to order: Grilled Octopus · Wild Scallops · Red Snapper · Homemade Mint Lemonade

25. 
    Hook & Reel Cajun Seafood & BarGraded A

    4.7★★★★★★★★★★(2,563)$$Seafood Restaurant · 2183b Ralph Avenue

    What to order: Crack&Peel Seafood Boil · Shrimp Seafood Boil · Lemon Pepper Wings · Loaded French Fries with Crab Meat

26. 
    Cap't LouiGraded A

    4.8★★★★★★★★★★(2,510)$$Seafood Restaurant · 34 West 32 Street

    What to order: 3 lb Boiler Combo (with Cap’t Loui sauce, medium spicy, incl · Oysters (fresh, half shell) · Garlic Noodles · Funnel Cake Fries or Beignets (dessert)

27. 
    Crab HouseGraded A

    4.3★★★★★★★★★★(2,466)US$90+Seafood Restaurant · 135 East 55 Street

    What to order: Pan Seared Scallops · Snow Crab Legs · Butter Lobster · Lobster Mac

28. 
    Red Hook Lobster PoundGraded A

    4.4★★★★★★★★★★(2,358)$$Seafood Restaurant · 284 Van Brunt Street

    What to order: Connecticut Lobster Roll · Maine Lobster Roll · New England Chowdah · Lobster Claw Bloody Mary

29. 
    Famous Fish MarketGraded A

    4.5★★★★★★★★★★(2,283)$Seafood Restaurant · 684 St Nicholas Avenue

    What to order: Fish Sandwich · Shrimp (basket/combo)

30. 
    Lure FishbarGraded A

    4.4★★★★★★★★★★(2,217)$$$Restaurant · 142 Mercer Street

    What to order: Spicy Tuna Crispy Rice · Sea Urchin (Uni) Bucatini · Deviled Eggs (with Caviar) · Mezzi Rigatoni Lobster Mac & Cheese

31. 
    Grand BanksGraded A

    4.3★★★★★★★★★★(2,033)$$$Oyster Bar Restaurant · Park N. Moore St. At West S

    What to order: Lobster Roll · Oyster Tower or Seafood Tower · Fresh Oysters · Ceviche

32. 
    Fish With YouGraded A

    4.8★★★★★★★★★★(1,865)$$Chinese Restaurant · 135-25a 40 Road

    What to order: Hot Oil Chinese Sauerkraut Fish (热炝酸菜鱼) · Boiled Fish with Pickled Cabbage & Green Pepper (青花椒酸菜鱼) · Brown Sugar Glutinous Rice Cake (红糖糍粑)

33. 
    Katana SushiGraded A

    4.4★★★★★★★★★★(133)Sushi Restaurant · 218 Columbia Street
34. 
    London Lennie'sGraded A

    4.4★★★★★★★★★★(1,914)$$$Seafood Restaurant · 63-88 Woodhaven Boulevard

    What to order: Seafood Tower · Oysters Rockefeller · Pistachio Crusted Halibut · Lennie’s Duet

35. 
    London Lennie'sGraded A

    4.4★★★★★★★★★★(1,914)$$$Seafood Restaurant · 63-88 Woodhaven Boulevard

    What to order: Oysters Rockefeller · Lobster Roll · Shellfish Castle/tower (e.g., Sinker)

36. 
    Sweet CatchGraded A

    4.7★★★★★★★★★★(1,747)$$Seafood Restaurant · 1222 Nostrand Avenue

    What to order: Fried Chicken and Shrimp Cornbread Waffle · Shrimp and Grits · Crab Deviled Eggs · Catfish and Grits

37. 
    DocksGraded A

    4.4★★★★★★★★★★(1,737)$$$Seafood Restaurant · 633 3 Avenue

    What to order: Smoky Baked Oysters · Maine Lobster Roll · Spicy Tuna & Avocado Sushi Roll · Signature Key Lime Pie

38. 
    OceanaGraded A

    4.5★★★★★★★★★★(1,549)$$$$Seafood Restaurant · 120 West 49 Street

    What to order: Seared Octopus · Lobster Scampi · Dover Sole a la Meunière · Sea Scallops

39. 
    Luke's LobsterGraded A

    4.4★★★★★★★★★★(1,508)$$Seafood Restaurant · 26 South William Street

    What to order: Lobster Roll Flight · Warm Butter Lobster Roll · New England Clam Chowder

40. 
    Jp's RestaurantGraded A

    4.3★★★★★★★★★★(1,497)$$$Seafood Restaurant · 703 Minnieford Avenue

    What to order: Stuffed fish / stuffed flounder · Whole broiled lobster · Large baked clams (Casino)

41. 
    Mermaid Oyster BarGraded A

    4.7★★★★★★★★★★(1,409)$$Seafood Restaurant · 89 Macdougal Street

    What to order: Oysters on the half shell (daily oyster happy hour) · Nearly Famous Lobster Roll · Smoked Gouda Mac & Cheese · Shrimp & Avocado Sliders

42. 
    The Crabby ShackGraded A

    4.3★★★★★★★★★★(1,457)$$Seafood Restaurant · 613 Franklin Avenue

    What to order: Our Famous Crab Roll · The Clobster Roll · Crab & Corn Chowder · Crabby Feast

43. 
    Peaches GrandGraded A

    4.3★★★★★★★★★★(1,388)$$American Restaurant · 4143 Clifton Place

    What to order: Blue Crab Spaghetti · Shrimp and Grits · Brown Butter Cake · Brooklyn Wings

44. 
    Geno's Fish & ChipsGraded A

    4.5★★★★★★★★★★(102)$Seafood Restaurant · 369 Nostrand Avenue
45. 
    Luke's LobsterGraded A

    4.3★★★★★★★★★★(1,383)$$Seafood Restaurant · 11 Water Street

    What to order: Lobster Roll · Seafood Roll Flight · Clam Chowder

46. 
    Surf BarGraded A

    4.4★★★★★★★★★★(1,355)$$Seafood Restaurant · 139 North 6 Street

    What to order: Pina Colada · Cali Shrimp Tacos · Fried Calamari · Coconut Shrimp

47. 
    Oceanic BoilGraded A

    4.5★★★★★★★★★★(1,287)$$Seafood Restaurant · 84-20 37 Avenue

    What to order: Oceanic Combo · 1 lb Shrimp (HEADLESS) · Cajun Lobster Mac and Cheese · Fried Oyster Basket

48. 
    The FultonGraded A

    4.2★★★★★★★★★★(1,330)$$$$Restaurant · 95 South Street

    What to order: Whole Black Sea Bass en Croûte · Longevity Noodles (with lobster) · Sea Scallops · Swordfish Milanese

49. 
    El Tina Fish Market & Seafood RestaurantGraded A

    4.5★★★★★★★★★★(1,251)Fish & Chips Restaurant · 500 West 207 Street

    What to order: seafood soup · fried fish · shrimp and mash

50. 
    Cull & Pistol (Lobster Place)Graded A

    4.6★★★★★★★★★★(1,219)$$Seafood Restaurant · 75 9 Avenue

    What to order: Lobster Bake · Lobster Roll (both Maine‑style and Connecticut‑style) · Raw oysters (especially during happy hour) · Shrimp Mole Tacos

Showing the top 50. Browse all 215 with filters.