Department of FoodieDepartment of FoodieStreamlined rooms in a relaxed lodging featuring a terrace & a bar, plus complimentary breakfast.
538 West 58 Street, Manhattan 10019From Google Maps reviews.
My friend, teen, and I did a very quick overnight trip to NYC from the DC area. We were there to see a matinee of a show, and the staff here were so accommodating to us. They have on-site parking in the garage right next door that was competitively priced, I felt, for our time there. They also offer luggage storage, which we took advantage of after we checked out, while we were at our show. Everyone was super friendly and accommodating. The rooms were clean, and the beds were super comfortable.
The folks are nice lot of construction around the building though for the roads. Also rooms are a bit smaller than others I have stayed at but still comfy. And the breakfast here is amazing 🤩 so many choices and hot food!
Good stay, but the "city view" was a disappointment. Overall, it was a positive experience. The staff was very polite, the room was clean, and the breakfast offered a good variety of options. However, there were a few letdowns. All the bread options seemed to be from the day before rather than freshly baked. More importantly, the room was advertised as having a "city view," but the only thing I could see were the garbage bins through very dirty windows. It’s a solid choice, but don't expect muc
From the Jun 23, 2025 health inspection. Lower-priority items are listed after the serious ones.
Clean utensils were stored where they could get dirty again.
Plumbing issues: poor drainage, backflow risk, or wastewater handled improperly.