Department of FoodieDepartment of Foodie
Established spot for basic brick-oven pizzas, with a few unique varieties like Clam Pie Oreganata.
What to order: Pizza Alla Vodka · Clam Pie Oreganata · Caldo E Dolce (Hot Honey) Pizza · Goodfella's Famous Fried CalamariFrom Google Maps reviews.
This place has quickly become one of my favorite spots on Staten Island. The atmosphere is great with a really clean modern bar, TVs for the games, and a lively dining room that makes it perfect whether you’re going out with friends or just grabbing dinner. The pizza here is phenomenal. The crust has that perfect crisp with a soft center and the ingredients taste really fresh. Every time I come here I end up ordering pizza because it is just that good. It is easily some of the best pizza on Sta
All I can say is wow. I ordered a large vodka pie and it was amazing. Now I can taste why this pizza is award winning. And that’s not even the best part. The chicken roll was phenomenal. Every bite better than the last. Very good food. Very filling. Absolutely recommend Goodfellas for unparalleled taste.
Always a great experience coming to Goodfellas, delicious food, great staff. Just amazing. I came here with my partner on New Year’s Eve and got a gluten free pesto shrimp pizza, he got the duck fat infused pork chop… chefs kiss ☺️ Our waitress Sheila B was a gem. Happy and blessed new year everyone ❤️
From the Jun 6, 2026 health inspection. Lower-priority items are listed after the serious ones.
No one on shift holds the required food-safety certificate.
Cold food was held above 41°F, warm enough for bacteria to grow.
Shelves, ledges, or equipment exteriors aren't clean or easy to clean.