Department of FoodieDepartment of FoodieNY-style pizza served by the slice in casual digs with friendly staff and efficient service.
From Google Maps reviews.
Excellent experience at Made In New York Pizza. The atmosphere is very pleasant and perfect for enjoying a good pizza. The prices are reasonable, and the pizza is delicious, fresh, and well-prepared. What definitely makes the difference is the service; the staff are incredibly attentive and friendly, and they also speak Spanish, which makes the experience much more comfortable. Without a doubt, a place I recommend and would return to without hesitation.
Excellent pizza, great cust and fantastic flavor. Vodka slice was very good. $5 a slice not bad for midtown. Would definitely recommend
I came back to Made in New York Pizza for my birthday and it was such a pleasure! This spot on 7th Ave has become my favorite pizza place of all. Quality slices, great prices, amazing ingredients. I am so happy and grateful that I could visit and hopefully I can come more often!
From the Jan 29, 2025 health inspection. Lower-priority items are listed after the serious ones.
Hot food was held below 140°F, cool enough for bacteria to grow.