Department of FoodieDepartment of FoodieClassic American diner with burgers, salads, entrees & more just a few blocks from Lincoln Center.
What to order: Old John’s Burger · Steak Frites · Braised Short Ribs · Greek Salad with ChickenFrom Google Maps reviews.
I was quite surprised by the quality of this place. I enjoyed my meal so much. The short rib is great. I loved the service - very attentive and caring. I love the decor of the place - very nostalgic, yet modern. They have a lovely unsweetened iced tea that has a great taste - ugh I love tea!
Perfect spot for a pre show dinner near the Lincoln center. The food is totally perfectly fine. The fries were actually above average!! The cocktails were above average too! I liked my frozen margarita x Aperol spritz thing. We could get a reservation day-of on a Wednesday night. They do not have gluten free bread. They have some gf dinner options but not a lot at the sub-$20 price range. I got an omelette.
During my NYC trip, I wanted to experience a classic diner and found Old John’s Luncheonette close to my hotel. It turned out to be a great choice! The food and atmosphere were great, but what really made the experience special was the service. Kathy was incredibly respectful and helpful regarding my halal diet. She took the time to make sure I had suitable options and made me feel completely comfortable. When I came back a second time, Kathy actually remembered my dietary restrictions — it wa
From the May 7, 2025 health inspection. Lower-priority items are listed after the serious ones.
Food was left exposed to possible contamination during storage, prep, or serving.
The required wash-your-hands sign wasn't posted.
Shelves, ledges, or equipment exteriors aren't clean or easy to clean.