Department of FoodieDepartment of FoodieSnug, no-frills pizza joint offering classic NYC, Chicago & Sicilian-style pies, plus heros & rolls.
What to order: Cheese Pizza · Fresh Mozzarella PizzaFrom Google Maps reviews.
Pizza Pete's, conveniently located near the Museum of Natural History, is a small establishment with very limited seating. Some might even describe its well-worn interior as a little dingy, but please, do not let that deter you. What this spot lacks in modern polish, it overwhelmingly makes up for in genuine warmth and exceptional food. The staff here are super friendly, creating an incredibly welcoming atmosphere that instantly makes you feel at home. Their hospitality truly elevates the entire
This place has been part of the community since I was a kid in the 80s. I am always happy to know it's there and still pumping out great fresh pizza! The guys behind the counter are the best! Going there always feels like home.
I rarely leave negative reviews, but this was, without question, the worst pizza I've ever eaten. I visited Pizza Pete on Columbus Avenue and 85th Street with my grandsons. I wanted to go to a nearby pizzeria where the pizza is made fresh by hand, but the boys wanted to try this place instead. The pizza tasted like cardboard covered with an overly sweet red sauce. The cheese had a strange rubbery texture and reminded me more of white paper than mozzarella. I've had dollar-slice pizza on 43rd S
From the Oct 20, 2025 health inspection. Lower-priority items are listed after the serious ones.
Food surfaces weren't washed and sanitized between uses.
Damaged canned food wasn't set aside and marked 'do not use'.
Plumbing issues: poor drainage, backflow risk, or wastewater handled improperly.
No working thermometer in the fridge or hot-holding unit.