From Google Maps reviews.
Outstanding bagels (crunchy outside, pillowy inside) plus dipping spreads of different flavors. Surprisingly good quality (for a chain store)! Must buy minimum of 3 bagels (can’t just stroll in for 1 bagel). Service is lightning fast! We tried 3 spreads (Salted Butter, Cream Cheese, and Vanilla); total came out to over $20. Located on one of the busiest luxury shopping streets in Manhattan. Staff was really nice, too.
Really enjoyed my bagel experience here. The bagels were warm and fresh, and the scallion cream cheese was excellent. I do understand the hype. I'm personally more of a salmon, red onion, and tomato guy when it comes to bagels, but that's a personal preference. These are clearly very high quality bagels! Big fan, would recommend.
Best bagel I ever had and best cream cheese. Amazing rapid fire friendly service. I love the rip and dip concept. They provide a ton of cream cheese for all three delicate soft incredible bagels. Solved the problem I have encountered at other local bagelries of them carelessly giving you half a bagel worth of cream cheese for $7. Pop up is the best quality and value per bagel by far. GO HERE!!!
From the Apr 9, 2025 health inspection. Lower-priority items are listed after the serious ones.

Dishes and utensils weren't being properly washed and sanitized.
Shelves, ledges, or equipment exteriors aren't clean or easy to clean.