Department of FoodieDepartment of Foodie
What to order: Orecchiette · Rosemary Focaccia · RigatoniFrom Google Maps reviews.
Only a couple blocks from my apartment, so super convenient. Not somewhere I’d go out of my way for. The space is lovely; warm, inviting interior with a small bar area, plus outdoor seating for nicer weather. Food: Went for lunch and ordered the margherita pizza, Caesar salad, and meatballs. Everything was decent but nothing memorable. The pizza had a nice thin crust and balanced tomato flavor, the Caesar was crisp and classic, and the meatballs were tender but lacked that rich, slow-simmered
We've walked by this place many times and liked the look of the place so we finally went there for brunch today. The positive is that the Bombolini's we had to start with were wonderful. Unfortunately, the other food was very mediocre. The Orecchiette was a small portion and not very interesting. The breakfast sandwich was mostly egg and a few slices of bacon slapped between a brioche bun and some potato chips, which felt way overpriced for what it was and taste-wise it wasn't interesting at al
We've been to the other Rosemary's but this was first time at Midtown. We loved our starters which we shared - Gem Caesar salad, brussel sprouts, foccacia bread and calamari. We all got variations of pastas for mains and liked those too. Plus two desserts...tiramisu (which was in a bowl and was a little small) and chocolate dessert which was fudgy and tasty. Wine list is varied and pretty reasonable, waitress "upsold us" to a different wine but we enjoyed it so was a good reco. Ambiance is fine,
From the Apr 21, 2026 health inspection. Lower-priority items are listed after the serious ones.
Food surfaces weren't washed and sanitized between uses.
Frozen food was thawed in an unsafe way.
Plumbing issues: poor drainage, backflow risk, or wastewater handled improperly.