Department of FoodieDepartment of FoodieFrom Google Maps reviews.
This is the second location of this frozen yogurt/froyo place, with the original one, of course, being on Madison near the Guggenheim. Speaking of location, this was the old tiny location of La Panineria, an excellent panini place which is now up the block. While they lack as many flavors as some other places, they have some fun toppings. I ordered the "Kid Size" as this is the solo one for $7.95 plus tax, which comes with one included topping. In terms of froyo flavor and texture, it was defini
The best Greek frozen yogurt in New York City! I’ve tried nearly every froyo spot in the city, and Madison Fare is my favorite. The quality and taste are amazing, and you can tell they genuinely care about the ingredients, from the rich, creamy yogurt to the fresh, high quality toppings. They are also generous with their portions. Consistently delicious and easily my top dessert spot!
The yogurt is great! I personally am not the biggest fan of this style of froyo. I prefer self serve and more dry toppings. This place does a lot of melted chocolate and knafeh, which are delicious but it’s a bit decadent for my tastes. I had a lovely time here though. The staff was so friendly.
From the Dec 11, 2025 health inspection. Lower-priority items are listed after the serious ones.
Staff hygiene fell short: soiled clothing, no hair covering, or unkempt nails.